Is There a Second Movie to I Can Only Imagine?

Is There a Second Movie to I Can Only Imagine? Yes—there’s exciting news for fans of the 2018 faith-based hit I Can Only Imagine. A sequel, aptly titled I Can Only Imagine 2, is officially on its way and set to hit theaters on February 20, 2026. Produced by Lionsgate and Kingdom Story Company, the film promises to continue the emotional and spiritual journey of MercyMe lead singer Bart Millard, whose life inspired the original movie.

🎬 What’s the Story This Time?

While the first film focused on Bart’s troubled childhood and the healing of his relationship with his father, the sequel shifts to his life after fame. I Can Only Imagine 2 explores Bart’s internal battles at the height of his success—his struggle with faith, identity, and the pressures of being a public figure in the Christian music world. This deeper dive into his personal and professional life adds new layers to the story, offering audiences a more complex and relatable portrait of a man navigating purpose and adversity.

📽️ Cast & Crew Highlights

The sequel reunites directors Andrew Erwin and Brent McCorkle, with a screenplay by McCorkle. Returning cast members include Dennis Quaid and John Michael Finley, while newcomers Milo Ventimiglia, Arielle Kebbel, and Sophie Skelton bring fresh energy to the ensemble. The production team also features Bart Millard himself, ensuring the story remains authentic and heartfelt.

💡 Why This Sequel I Can Only Imagine Matters?

The original film was a surprise box office success, grossing over $83 million worldwide and becoming one of the most successful Christian films of all time. Its message of forgiveness and redemption resonated across faith communities and mainstream audiences alike. With I Can Only Imagine 2, the filmmakers aim to build on that legacy, offering a story that’s not just inspirational but also honest about the complexities of spiritual life after fame.